Monday, November 27, 2006

Upon Further Review

They not only wished they did it better the first time; they actually admitted they got it wrong in the first place! So said 13different newspaper critics in Upon Further Review: Critics change their minds, a feature article in this weekend's Sunday Chicago Tribune Arts section. And how wonderfully refreshing is that?!

Take a look at who had the nerve (and moxie) to admit the err of their ways:
  • Music Critic, Scott L. Powers
  • Rock Critic, Greg Kot
  • Movie Critic, Michael Phillips
  • Movie Critic, Michael Wilmington
  • Music Critic, Howard Reich
  • Classical Music Critic, John von Rhein
  • Theatre Critic, Chris Jones
  • Television Critic, Maureen Ryan
  • Arts Critic, Sid Smith
  • Art Critic, Alan Artner
  • Architecture Critic, Blair Kamin
  • Restaurant Critic, Phil Vettel

These are big names in Chicago critic circles. Yet each person was man or woman enough to do what they called a 'critical reversal.'

Admitting you goofed when you really have is not a sign of weakness, as many would have you believe. It's a sign of objectivity, of maturity, of excellence. Yes, that's right, copping to your mistakes is a sign of excellence, because it's often not the mistake - it's what you do immediately after, or as a result of, the mistake - that matters more.

If you learn from it - and demonstrate that learning - then chances are good the error won't be held against you. In fact, you might even be commended for your honesty and integrity.

But if you try and pretend it never happened - or continue to make the same mistake over and over again - then chances are good that this particular example is just one more brick in an ever-growing wall separating you from lasting success.

Here's an exercise to clean the slate: List out a number of mistakes you know you've made this year and what you learned from each of them. Then go apply your learning in as meaningful a way as possible.

You'll feel better and the world will be a better place.

Labels: ,

2 Comments:

Blogger Erik said...

Great post, Barry. Admitting mistakes is way too rare in business, and in life. Even rarer is someone who goes the extra mile in fixing the mistake better than it ever could have been in the first place.

I blogged about that and linked to you over at: www.erikmazzone.com

Wednesday, November 29, 2006 10:21:00 AM CST  
Anonymous Barry Zweibel said...

Thanks, Erik. A long time ago a boss said to me, "I didn't hire you for what you're able do today, I hired you for what you will be able do do in the future. That means you're going to be asked to do things you don't already know how to do. And that means you're going to mess a few things up along the way. So when you screw up - and I do mean when - just make sure you learn enough from the experience to make it worth my while to have to clean up after you."

Saturday, December 2, 2006 12:06:00 PM CST  

Post a Comment

<< Home